Book chosen for them, with a note inside
Pick a book because of something they said, and write why on the first page. The note is the gift.
You drew a name you barely know and a $25 limit. Pick one thing you know about them (coffee, plants, reading) and choose a small, good version of it.
Lists are a starting point. Tell the generator one or two things about this particular person and get ideas no list would include.
New to this? Our guide to choosing a gift explains why recipients and givers judge gifts differently.
A tea sampler, a good notebook, a small plant or a mug warmer are safe and useful.
Whatever the group agreed; $20–25 is a very common limit.